9 Best Eyebrow Pencil in 2021 To Make Gorgeous Brow Shapes

Best Eyebrow Pencil

Are you looking for the best eyebrow pencil to get gorgeous brow Shapes? These are the best, from Blink Brow Bar to HD Brows and more, whether you like a full or natural … We asked makeup artists to recommend the best waterproof eyebrow pencils and this same type of product like waterproof mascara that will actually survive whatever summer and winter. To maximize and shape your eyebrows, you need the best brow pencil, brow gel, and brow powder you can buy.

Eyebrow Trends

Our brows must now be transformed to fit the times as we keep up with the fashion trends. The newest look has shifted to bold, full brows, and in the aftermath of the over-plucking trend in the late 1990s, we must now rely on the very best eyebrow pencils and products to resurrect and achieve a fuller look.

Why an Eyebrow Pencil is Important?

Eyebrow Pencils are a very essential eye makeup products that apply color to the eyebrows. As women age, the eyebrows naturally become thinner and lighter, making them look older. And If you want to solve this problem with a good quality eyebrow pencil it’s possible. Eyebrow shape can have a huge impact on your face shape. For example, a flat eyebrow tends to create the effect of shortening your face shape, which is great for women with a longer face. On the other hand, if you have a small face, avoid long, thick eyebrows.

Finally, another important reason for grooming your eyebrows is to maintain your overall look and help you to feel more polished and confident. If you spend time on your foundation, eye shadow, and every other aspect of your face, you could look unbalanced if you avoid your eyebrows.

Choosing The Right Eyebrow Pencil For You

First, picking the shade is the most important factor because the color makes a world of difference to your eyebrows. If you’re in doubt, always choose the lighter shade as you can always apply several applications to add more definitions.

Eyebrow Pencil Tips

Once you’ve purchased the right eyebrow pencil for you, it’s time to focus on the application stage. Remain as steady as possible and apply light strokes. Avoid pressing too hard with the pencil as this will create an unnatural look that is hard to reverse. We suggest using a comb to brush your brows in the direction of the hair as this is the way your hair naturally grows.

Also, to ensure that your eyebrows look as natural as possible, we recommend avoiding drawing on the top line of your brow as this can create a weighty appearance. Instead, focus on the arch and underneath the brow.

The Best Eyebrow Pencils Available Right Now

Read our reviews on the top 10 best eyebrow pencils in 2019 out there to help you flawlessly create, shape, and fill your brows. Your daily brow routine needs to be updated to gain the beautiful shape that we are all striving to achieve.

Top Selected Products and Reviews

1. L’OrÃal Paris Stylist Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

These are the most natural-looking eyebrow pencils. The color spot for the dark blonde hair doesn’t look splotchy, and with one stroke of the spoolie- on the end, it just looks like a natural eyebrow.
The consistency goes on with light touches, just the way it’s supposed to, and it fills in light spots without clinging too much to the hair itself.
Makes for an even-looking brow. This is a very fine brow pencil that allows you to control exactly the thickness.
The result is natural-looking. Most of the women like that the pencil comes with a brush at the opposite end for blending. This helps to soothe out any obvious lines and tidies up your actual eyebrows.


  • This eyebrow pencil works pretty well. It’s easy to apply and the skinny tip makes it look more natural
  • Great for a long-wearing eyebrow pencil
  • This works Very well with my LIGHT blonde hair. The brush makes this look completely bendable.
  • Pretty nice color (dark brown is good for black hair without being overwhelming.)
  • The point is small enough to draw convincing lines.


  • The MOST ANNOYING part is that both ends of the pencil BROKE OFF within a few weeks of use! Sure, you can still use it, but it’s pretty inconvenient to use a tiny pencil/brush. If you pop it back into the plastic base, it will just pop out again when you take the cap off.
  • The formula is kinda crumbly and not smooth

2. Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Pencil

The color is a deep, blackish-brown which matches the brow nicely. The consistency is good–not too creamy, not too waxy–and doesn’t wear off easily. And, the price is right.

  • If you have a scar in the middle of the eyebrow that makes a decent eyebrow line challenging. This does better than anything else.
  • It’s affordable. You simply can’t beat the price. If it were bad quality, that wouldn’t matter. But this is affordability + quality = value. If you want even more savings, you can get it on subscribe & save.
  • Texture. This goes on so smoothly, and it stays on. Doesn’t flake
  • The color (medium brown) is just right. It’s really medium brown

Check Out the Latest Price on Amazon

3. Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil

Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil
Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil
This pencil is perfect in every way (as much as it could be). The color is a nice, buildable dark brown that would work for all shades of brunette and black hair. The spoolie- the brush is actually functional and useful for blending out pencil strokes and shaping hairs into place. The pigment/color is rich and lasts all day so long as you don’t touch your brows. The pencil produces fine lines that are great for filling in sparse brows.


  • Blends into eyebrows nicely– makes them defined, yet natural-looking
  • If you are blond, then you can use brown to go a little darker. With the lighter versions, it makes your eyebrows look pasty
  • The product runs out fast! There’s very little product in the applicator. You’re getting less pencil than you are with most other similar products


  • Not yet

Finally, you can buy it without hesitation. It’s affordable, and befit on all typeface shapes

Check out the Latest Price on Amazon

4. WUNDER2 WUNDERBROW Long Lasting Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

WUNDER2 WUNDERBROW Long Lasting Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil
WUNDER2 WUNDERBROW Long Lasting Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

The formula is great and the color is perfect, this fills in your brows and tames them as well so no additional gel or hairspray is needed. That being said, the applicator brush is HUGE and hard to work with for a precise and natural application, after applying you have to go back and clean up the edges, a smaller brush would help with this issue.


  • Long-lasting (1-3 days)
  • Good in dry and humid/wet weather
  • Natural-looking or bold (depending on application)
  • Easy to clean up/fix


  • The steep learning curve for application
  • Easy to overdo it
  • Brush in a product is not great

5. Etude House Drawing Eye Brow Pencil

Etude House Drawing Eye Brow Pencil
Etude House Drawing Eye Brow Pencil
If your eyebrows are almost gone due to thyroid problems, no problem. You can paint it over your eyebrows over the years like a natural eyebrow. The Etude House Drawing Eye Brow Pencil will make them look too dark or too dense.


  • This color looks natural
  • It’s made your eyebrows look very smooth
  • These eyebrows nice texture and long-lasting
  • This is wonderful, easy to apply, and affordable
  • It’s a better eyebrow for the beginner’s and expertise
  • It has the best ash brown color that’ll also match your natural hair color
  • The perfect shade that’ll exactly match your eyebrows and its color stay lasts all-day

6. NYX PROFESSIONAL Makeup Micro Eyebrow Pencil

This is very close to many higher products. My gripe about it is that the color is too warm/orangery for my coloring. I am very fair and my eyebrows are very light so I need an ashy color. Taupe is usually fine but theirs was too warm. It is a terrific product other than that

7. Chella Eyebrow Pencil

Chella Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie (eyebrow brush) - Tantalizing Taupe
Chella Eyebrow Pencil

8. Eyebrow Pencil 2 Packs

Eyebrow Pencil 2 Packs, Waterproof Smudge-proof Brow Pencil with Brow Brush
Eyebrow Pencil 2 Packs
“Great brow pencil that makes me feel confident!” – by Laura Stegner
It’s a super impressive brow pencil! I have been using this product daily for the past week and I can’t imagine leaving my house without using it before I leave. It makes me feel more confident about myself. Please look at my before and after pictures of my eyebrows and how much it changes the look them.

9. Hey Beauty Eyebrow Pencil

Hey Beauty Eyebrow Pencil with Brow Brush, Waterproof Automatic Makeup Cosmetic Tool for Dark Brown
Hey Beauty Eyebrow Pencil


  • It’s a good eyebrow pencil but IT IS NOT WATERPROOF

10. Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil

Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
If you are tried almost on every brand, from drugstore to high end, in many different styles as well (powders, gels, etc). For a long time, then you can use MAC’s pencil in a fling. However, this is one of the Best Eyebrow Pencil that works quickly and knew there had to be a comparable product that would last longer for a more reasonable price.

11. Revlon Color Stay Brow Pencil

Revlon Color Stay Brow Pencil
Revlon Color Stay Brow Pencil

12. Maybelline Brow Define & Fill Duo, Soft Brown, Defining Pencil with Filling Powder

Maybelline Brow Define & Fill Duo, Soft Brown, Defining Pencil with Filling Powder
Maybelline Eye Brown Pencil
This product is hands down amazing. The defining side of the pencil provides a smooth soft texture for a natural look, and the powder side of the brush allows for a soft filler where brows are sparse.

13. Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil & Gel by Color Stay, Light Brown

Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil & Gel by ColorStay, Light Brown
Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil & Gel by Color Stay, Light Brown