14 Best Eye Makeup Remover Reviews & Buying Guide of 2023

These ten best eye makeup remover reviews will guide you in choosing out of the various brands on the market.

Eyelid skins need special care because they are delicate. If you make a wrong choice, it could damage your eyes. Fortunately, using the best eye makeup removers will prevent eye damage if you choose the best. Information here is to guide you to choose the best.

After searching through the market for the best models and checking through experts and user’s opinions these ten top products were chosen. All you need do is to go through the reviews and make a choice.

If you spend your money on any of these recommended products, you can leap the benefits for a long time. Keep reading to learn more about these 14 eye makeup remover products. You will convince yourself that these are the best you can buy with money.

What Is The Best Eye Makeup Remover?

This is not an easy question to answer, because there are lots of models out there, and these promise to offer the best. Do not go by the advertiser’s words, rather look out for expert’s opinions about the best.

The best makeup remover does away with stubborn mascara and debris from the eyes. You do not need to at your eyelashes or to scrub your eyes before you use this kind of product.

Furthermore, such products are fragrance-free and are good for sensitive eyes. Besides, it has to be extra gentle and free of any kind of hypoallergenic effects.

After comparing various products out there, we choose Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover as the best, so you can buy with money.

It can serve as a cleanser and it is good for sensitive eyes. This product is nongreasy, and it removes waterproof mascara. Because of the efficiency dermatologists and ophthalmologists approve it.

What can be used as an eye makeup remover?

You cannot use anything you see in the market or that goes by the name makeup remover. It must feature those things that protect your eyes and removes makeup with ease.

The first such has to enhance the eye’s appearance. Safety is the issue when you are making a choice. research shows that the best is from natural products that do not have any negative side effects.

When you are making your choice consider the kind of ingredients it contains. The best eye makeup remover acts fast and easily without leaving residues and side effects behind.

The formulation process is also important; it does not contain harmful microorganisms. Safety of ingredients is critical and you must bear this at the back of your mind when you are making that choice.

Here are the safe ingredients to consider when you are looking for the best eye makeup remover mineral oil, benzyl alcohol, glycerin, sodium lauryl sulfate as well as polylobate 20.

What is the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes?

You cannot use every makeup remover you find on the market for a sensitive eye. Look for a product that enhances your comfort and good for sensitive skin like the eyes.

When you are looking for a such product, you consider several products. Look for a product that is ammonium-free. Such irritates the skin. Furthermore, search for a makeup remover that is alcohol-free. It consumes barriers that protect the eyes.

The other factor to ignore is the issue of fragrance. The smell will not be good and it can smell chemicals. Most importantly, if you are allergic to this kind of product, then you must search for it carefully to make a choice.

Check the quality and do not opt for those that can cause allergic reactions. I consider any of the ten products reviewed above, you can make a great choice since most of them are good for sensitive eyes.

What is the best eye makeup remover for waterproof mascara?

The best eye makeup remover for waterproof mascara is the product that does not have any side effects and can remove every residue easily. A lot of removers are there but you do not have to use all of them because they can remove. The first thing is to consider the safety of use. Given this, the method of removal is very important.

We invite you to continue to read this review to know why these recommended products were selected. You require a quality product that can safely remove that debris from the eyes.

When you talk of quality, consider the kind of ingredients available in these products and know whether you can use them. For instance, when you are making that choice, do not opt for anything with ammonium inside it. Besides such a product has to be alcohol-free. The issue of allergies and fragrances are critical factors when you are looking for the perfect remover.

What is the best natural eye makeup remover?

When you mention the word natural, it means that it must be an organic product. Certain oils are good in this removal. You cannot use all kinds of oils for that purpose. Avoid any product with hair astringents from it such as alcohol. Using products from natural ingredients is the best since they do not have any side effects.

Moreover, such products are one hundred percent natural and the prices are bound to be stable and affordable. All the products reviewed below are from one hundred percent natural ingredients. Because of that, the makers of these products considered your safety before they went to the factory to manufacture them.

You should opt for natural ingredients because they are safe and effective when you apply them to the eyes. They are gentle to the body and they do not traumatize your eyes and your skin. It must be comfortable and convenient to use them to achieve the kind of cleaning result you want.

What is the safest eye makeup remover?

The safest eye makeup remover does not have any side effects when you apply them to the eye. It does not damage the eyes and does not traumatize the skin in any way. Moreover, such must come from natural ingredients and they must be safe to the eyes.

You can use those makeup clothes which can remove debris from the eyes. The problem with this kind of clothes is that they can leave residues behind. The implication here is that cannot effectively remove them.

Therefore, the best remover must not leave behind anything in the form of residue. All the products listed below make the list because of their effectiveness in this kind of removal and they do not leave anything behind.

You can consider any of them and choose according to your budget and personal preferences. These are good products and you will get real value for your money.

Factors to consider when buying eye makeup remover

First-time buyers may not find it easy when they are choosing the best makeup remover. If you are one of them, you need expert advice. Here are some of the factors that guide you when you are making the choice.


The most important factor to consider is the issue of safety. Do not opt for a product that can damage the eyes and which cannot remove everything with ease.


Furthermore, think of the kind of removal service that the product can offer. It must be able to remove all kinds of makeup including waterproof mascara.


Most importantly, the product must have a long-lasting effect. You do not need to repeat the same process several times. It is not good for the eyes.

Oil-free eye makeup removers

When you are making a choice ensure that the product is oil-free. Most of the oily products do leave grease and oil behind the eyes and that makes it a bad experience for the users.


Besides, consider the skin type before you make a choice. While making a choice, do not go for anything that can hurt the skin.

Ophthalmological Tested

Most importantly, you must it for eye safety. There must be evidence from experts that the products are safe to apply to the eyes.

Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

If you have sensitive eyes and you wear eye lenses, you must ensure that the product is safe to apply to the eyes. Do not go for anything that can compound your eye problems.

1. Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover & Cleanser for Sensitive Eyes

The product is the editor’s choice and you can see from the features that it merits the top position it occupies here. It is nongreasy and removes all kinds of eye makeup. The most outstanding aspect is that it is approved by experts in dermatology and ophthalmology.

It is available in 5.5 fluid-ounce bottles and it is one hundred percent oil-free liquid. Because it comes from one hundred percent raw materials, it is safe for the eyes. It is a multipurpose product that cleans, treats, moisturize as well as protects the eyes. When it comes to safety it is the best and that is why it tops the list here. The product has other attributes that stand it out in the market.


  • Does not contain Neutrogena
  • Soothing to use
  • Tested before release


  • Multipurpose make up remover
  • Protects the eye
  • Healthy and safe ingredients
  • Best for waterproof mascara


  • Can be discomforting

A good quality eye makeup remover. Contains the best natural ingredients which are safe for the eyes. This product does different things to the eyes such as removing makeup, protecting the eyes, moisturizing, and most important can treat the eyes. Choose this product today.

2. Amazon Brand – Solimo Eye Makeup Remover, Removes Waterproof Mascara, Dermatologist Tested, 5.5 Fluid Ounce

As you can get from the name, this product is a high-profile eye makeup remover. It is a multipurpose remover since it offers other benefits to the eyes. This can remove all kinds of debris from the eyes including waterproof mascara. It is one hundred percent oil-free and experts approve it before it comes to the market.

This makes the list because of the reputation in removing all kinds of makeups including those stubborn makeups that defy all solutions. It is a product of America and comes with the safest natural ingredients that you can ever think of in this world.

There are other benefits you can derive from this product. For instance, research shows that it is useful in fighting breakouts. Given that, it serves as facial cleansers.


  • Perfect Amazon brand
  • Dermatologists tested and approved
  • Contains One 5.5-fluid ounce bottle


  • Can remove all kinds of makeups
  • Does not leave any residue behind
  • Easy and simple to clean after use
  • Contains healthy and natural ingredients


  • Works well but may not be the best

This is a safe and healthy product to use. Before release professionals tested and approved it. besides, it can remove all kinds of makeup and does not leave behind any residue. It is just the best and you can opt for it.

3. No Makeup Easy Rinse Makeup-Removing Cleanser

When you consider the formulation you see that it comes with the best natural ingredients available in the market. because of that it is safe to use and can clean the makeup without difficulties.

This product is good for anybody irrespective of your sex, you can comfortably use this product. Because of the formulation, this product is also gentle to the eyes as it cleans and removes all the dirt without difficulty.

It does not even strip you of the natural oils and it leaves the skin soft and great. After the application, you notice that you are younger because it rejuvenates the skin. It can do away with different kinds of skin impurities including eye makeups and other debris in the eyes.

It offers the best because it is formulated with the most powerful ingredients that are available in the market today. Choose today if you want the best for your eyes and if you want to look younger.


  • It helps prepare the skin for perfect makeup
  • Can remove makeups as well
  • Great for the body and skin


  • Dual-purpose application
  • A high-quality skincare product
  • Good for the body because of the nourishing ingredients
  • Rejuvenates the skin


  • Relatively new

This is relatively new and there is no complaint about it. The product could be the brand you are waiting for. Why not try it now and see the differences it can make. It contains superior natural ingredients.

4. Simple Kind to Skin Eye Makeup Remover, Dual Effect, 3.38 Ounce

The performance of this kind of product depends on the ingredients. This product features natural and safe ingredients. The product is effortless when it comes to the removal of waterproof mascara and other debris in the eyes.

It is very simple to use as you do not need to rub your eyes to remove those things. The product is also very safe for the eyes since it can nourish as well as hydrate the eyes. It makes the eyelids healthier and feels better as well. Furthermore, it is good for the eye area as it makes it feel soft and it hydrates it as well. When you use this, it does not have any sticky residue.

If you are looking for a product that can cleanse your eyes effortlessly, then you can always think of this product. The product is not known for any carbon emissions. Even if you use contact lenses or you have sensitive skin, you can use this comfortably. Besides, other fantastic features make the product great.


  • Dual effect eye makeup
  • No harsh rubbing
  • Remove waterproofed makeup


  • It is very kind to the skin
  • Simple to use
  • Good for sensitive eyes
  • Great and effective


  • Can disappoint

It comes with everything you want. This product removes all kinds of makeup with ease and it comes with no side effects. If you are looking for the best, you can always consider this product.

5. Clinique Naturally Gentle Eye Make-Up Remover, 2.5 Ounce

Clinique naturally makeup remover is one of the best in the market today. It is composed of the best quality natural materials and that is why it is safe and good to use. Because of the effectiveness, the product can effectively remove all signs of makeup. It ensures complete removal and can comfort and calm all parts of the eye area.

When you use this product, you will be happy and the outcome is better than what you get elsewhere. The remover is also effective. It does not matter the kind of skin you have, this product is suitable for that. If you are interested in quality, you can always think of this one. It comes with everything you want and that is why it makes the list of the best in the market.


  • Safely removes makeup
  • Does not leave any residue behind
  • Great for all skin types


  • This is suitable for all skin types
  • It is very effective
  • The product is safe to use
  • Comfort and calm the eye area


  • It may not be the best for sensitive eyes

If you are looking for this kind of product, look for the natural product. This is safe to the eye area and can remove all traces of makeup. It is safe to use and highly recommended.

6. AHAVA Eye Make-up Remover, 4.2 FL Oz

It features aqua mineral spring water and other naturally occurring ingredients. This is the best formulation you can have today. Experts approve it before it makes it to the market. furthermore, the product is not only gentle to the body, but it is also effective.

It performs different functions when you apply it to the eyes. The first is that it cleanses and removes all kinds of makeup. Furthermore, it helps the eye especially the most delicate part of it which it nourishes and makes healthier. The minerals are powerful enough and come with nourishing powers.

This product is also very powerful and because of that, it removes all kinds of makeups including the stubbornest ones. This product works in two ways to effectively remove dirt from the eyes.

The product can achieve the best result when you apply it before you wash your face and you can apply it using a cotton pad as well as a ball. It acts gently in removing makeup.


  • Gentle and effective
  • Removes and cleanses
  • Nourishing to the eyes


  • It removes waterproofed makeup
  • This product nourishes the eyes
  • Removes stubborn makeup
  • It does not have any side effects


  • Expensive

It could be expensive but effective. If you want to safely remove makeup from your eyes with confidence, then you can rely on this product. It is a perfect product and you will feel happy using it.

7. Albolene Moisturizing Cleanser | 3-in-1 Skin Care Product: Makeup Remover, Facial Cleanser, and Moisturizer | No Soap or Water Needed | 12 Ounces | Pack of 1

The model is also another great one that is good for eye makeup. Its greatness lies in the fact that you can use it for different purposes which include using it for skin conditioning. The product also has a moisturizing effect. It makes a great difference to the portion of the eyes you apply it.

The other important aspect of the product is that it is highly protective and it can protect the eyes and the skin as well. Any investment you make on this is worth it, and you can use it for different purposes. This comes with everything you need.

This brand is not new and over the years, it enjoys popularity among people satisfied with the performance. It is unique because of the wonderful ingredients combination and these are all-natural ingredients. The product is equally fragrance-free and does not feature any preservatives and paraben.

To remove makeup, you do not need to apply water or soap. It does everything very well. This is very fast and effective. Look no further because this product comes with everything you need.


  • 3 in 1 care product
  • Contains five simple ingredients
  • Multi care skin product


  • Cleanses makeup easily and gently
  • Very effective in removing waterproof mascara
  • Very easy and simple to use
  • Safe and protective ingredients


  • Does not perform as expected

Superior eye care product, this product does not only remove makeups, but it also makes the eyes secure and it does not have any negative side effects. Most importantly, it is very easy and simple to apply this solution. It is simply the best.

8. Ocusoft Lid Scrub Foaming Eyelid Cleanser, 7.25 Fluid Ounce

Some people use it as an eyelid, but it is best known as a cleanser. The design makes it the most popular choice in the market and it is doctor recommended. When you use this, you will have value for your money and instant foaming means that you are going to have the makeup cleaned instantly.

Moreover, it is healthy to use as it does not irritate the eyes or the skin. The overall health of your eyes is very important and that is why this important product is good for your eyes. Since it is safe to apply since it does not have any side effects. When you want the best, you can opt for this. It comes with everything you want.


  • Instant foaming cleanser
  • Does not irritate the skin
  • In economy size


  • This product is gentle to the body
  • The product does not irritate the eye as well as the skin
  • Removes all debris from the eye
  • Solves eyelid problems


  • Does not smell well

It is the kind of makeup remover you are waiting for. This can remove all the debris from the eyes and has other medicinal values. If you are suffering from other eyelid conditions, you can rely on this product as the most effective solution.

9. Burt’s Bees Eye Makeup Remover Pads, 35 Count

Burt’s Bees product is among the best in the market. It uses a pad and that makes it effective in makeup removals. The product can serve different purposes. For instance, it serves as a moisturizing pad. It is possible because of the quality formulation.

The other important attribute is the effective cleansing purpose. This product can reach all parts of the eyes and this ensures complete removal of all dirt and oil including makeups. The truth is that you can use this one with confidence and you will be happy with the outcome.

Moreover, there is nothing like irritation or any side effects when you use this wonderful product. Before its release to the market, experts tested and confirmed the quality. It is effective in wiping makeup and it does that gently. The cleaning process is not even complicated and it is a one-step process and the benefits would be there for a very long time.


  • Gentle wipes
  • One-step cleanser
  • Effective cleaning solution


  • This clinically removes debris from the eyes
  • It pampers the eyes as they cleanse
  • This is a 95 percent natural formulation
  • It can reach all the corners of the eyes


  • A user complains it is not effective

This is dermatologically tested before it was released to the market. It is very effective and can remove all debris in the eyes with ease. Its ingredients are 95 percent natural and you have real value when you buy this item.

10. LASHVIEW Eyelash extension remover cream, light Aloe Flavor Cream, Eyelash Adhesive Remover, Low Irritation Cream for Sensitive Skin,5g

LASHVIEW eyelash product is another high-end remover you can use today to remove makeup with ease. This product does not irritate and it does not come with any other side effects. Furthermore, the product is gentle to the and it does not irritate.

When it comes to the removal of dirt from the eye, this product is effective and highly reliable. It comes with a special fragrance and not a stimulating smell. The product is a flavor to use and the odor is pleasant as well.

And when it comes to quality, it is the best and has been tested. Experts in lots of professional areas tested and certified this product. Furthermore, it is safe to use and it is easy to control as well. When you apply, it does not slip to your eyes and cause havoc.

The quality of this product is assured and you have value for your money when you use this product. It makes the list because of the safety and performance.


  • Special fragrance
  • Superior quality cream
  • Safe formula


  • This formulation is safe to use
  • It smells very well because of the special fragrance
  • A superior quality product
  • The best quality


  • A user complains it is not that effective

This brand is another superior quality eye makeup remover product you can try your hand. There is no side effect and it is a superior quality product. Choose this product today.

11. La Roche-Posay Respectissime Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover, 4.2 FL Oz

A user-friendly makeup remover, this product can remove all kinds of makeups including waterproofed mascara. The result is instant and it removes all kinds of makeups without difficulties. You do not even need to rub your eyes when you use it.

Even if it rubs the eyes, it does not irritate. It is good for sensitive eyes and it does not have a bad odor. Furthermore, this is paraben-free and it was professionally tested and approved safe to use. You can use it to remove all kinds of makeup include face and eye makeup.

To get the best results, you must shake it very well before you begin to apply it using a cotton pad. It comes with everything you want and that is why it makes the list.


  • Gentle to the eyes
  • Does not rub
  • No irritation


  • Gentle waterproof eye makeup remover
  • Bi-phase formulation
  • No bad fragrance
  • Quality product


  • Causes milia around the eyes

A first-class makeup remover product. This solution is effective in doing away with makeup and other debris in the eyes. When it comes to quality, it does not compare with any other products it has an edge over others.

12. Neutrogena Makeup Remover Eraser Stick with Vitamin E, Easy-to-Use and Travel-Friendly Makeup Removing Gel Pen for On-the-Go Touch-Ups of Stray or Smudged Eyeliner, Lipstick, and More, 0.04 oz.

It is another wonderful product from Neutrogena. The makeup remover is another wonderful product and you can use it to remove all kinds of debris, dirt and to cleanse the eyes as well. It is a perfect solution for all kinds of eye dirt. This product is very simple and easy to use and it is a versatile remover product. It is not associated with any side effects.


  • Comes with vitamin E ingredients
  • Travel friendly
  • Portable


  • This product is highly portable
  • Quite easy and simple to use
  • Vitamin E formulation for the health of the eyes
  • Very effective in the removal


  • A user complained it is greasy and hard to use

It is a high-end brand and it can remove your eyes debris within the shortest time. this product is revolutionary and has great benefits to the eyes. Choose it right now

13. Maybelline New York Expert Eyes Moisturizing Eye Makeup Remover, For Waterproof Eye Makeup, 2.3 fl. Oz

It is gentle to the eyes and can remove all kinds of makeup including waterproof mascara and others. The moisturizing feature is great since it makes the eyes healthy. It is gentle and not associated with any fragrance.


  • Fragrance-free
  • Moisturizing remover
  • Gentle to the eyes


  • Very effective in waterproof mascara removal
  • Gently washes away the debris
  • Simple and easy to use
  • Compact design and portable


  • Not the best for contacts-wearers

This remover is manufactured by experts. It contains the most important ingredients that can remove makeup, waterproof mascara, and moisturize the eyes as well. If you are interested in quality, you can always think of this product. It is one of the best.

14. Almay Longwear & Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover Pads, 80 Count

Almay is another maker of great makeup remover. It is effective and it can remove all kinds of makeup from the eyes. The product is safe to use and healthy to use.


  • Great for traveling
  • Removes all kinds of makeup
  • Comes with necessary removal tools


  • It is portable
  • The product is very effective
  • Comes with remover pads for effective cleansing
  • Great product


  • Put films on the eyes

It is a one hundred percent makeup remover with no default. The product is effective in the removal of all kinds of makeups and it can make the eyes to be healthy.

Final Verdict

These are the best eye makeup remover products you can buy with money. They are recommended because of their wonderful features. First, they are safe and easy to use. They are healthy as well. Most importantly, you can use this for all kinds of makeup removal. Choose any of the recommended products and you will have value for your money.